Dumped by Someone You Settled For

 What Was I Thinking? The Harsh Reality of Dating Down

I've been there, dating someone who, by all accounts, seemed like a lucky catch... for them. He wasn't my usual type – not as fit, not as polished. Friends raised their eyebrows, but I thought I was being open-minded, giving a chance to someone who wasn't my usual 'shiny and perfect.'

Read Our Guide To Gay Dating Manual

 The Unexpected Blow: When Mr. Mediocre Dumps You

But then, he did the unthinkable – he dumped me. The guy who, let's be honest, was punching way above his weight. The shock was like a slap in the face. I was scandalized. How could someone I was clearly 'settling' for decide I wasn't enough?

 The Conceited Confession: Wrestling with Shallow Feelings

I'm not proud to admit it, but it hurt more than if a 'suitable' guy had done it. It wasn't just a breakup; it felt like a judgment on me. There I was, thinking I was the catch, and suddenly, I'm the one being thrown back in the sea. The conceit in that thought was not lost on me, but it stung nonetheless.

 The Mirror of Self-Reflection: Facing Uncomfortable Truths

This experience forced me to look in the mirror. Was I really so shallow that getting dumped by someone 'less attractive' hurt more? It was a tough pill to swallow, realizing that my self-conception was so tied to being 'better' than the person I was dating.

 The Aftermath: Navigating the Wreckage of a Bruised Ego

In the aftermath, my ego took a hit. It wasn't just about being single again; it was grappling with the reality that I wasn't the prize I thought I was. My friends tried to console me, but their words felt hollow. "You were too good for him anyway," they'd say. But if that were true, why did it end this way?

 The Harsh Lesson: Understanding the Cost of Conceit

The hardest lesson was understanding the cost of my conceit. In trying to be non-superficial, I ended up being more superficial than ever. It wasn't about him or his looks; it was about how I valued myself in relation to him. And in that, I had failed spectacularly.

 The Road to Recovery: Rebuilding a Shattered Self-Image

Rebuilding my self-image has been a journey. It's one thing to know you're being shallow, and another to change that mindset. Dating is no longer about 'dating up' or 'dating down.' It's about finding someone who challenges and respects me, not someone who simply looks good on my arm.

In the end, the worst pain wasn't the breakup. It was the brutal realization of my own shallowness. It's a lesson I'm still learning: in love, it's not about who's 'better' or 'worse.' It's about finding someone who sees you for more than just your surface.